When I get dressed in the morning the overriding thing I consider is whether or not my husband will like what he sees. It’s archaic of me I know, but there you have it. Modesty is no longer an issue not because I dress immodestly, but because hyper-focusing on that often meant that I was dressed in a way that my husband hated. I looked religious enough, but was unattractive to my husband. This was counter intuitive.
Once that phase passed I found myself in another one, where I always seemed to be overdressed compared to the other suburban mothers at the park, the PTA, and the supermarket. Every day when I went out I met the same refrain: “You look nice. Where are you going today?” I was going right where I was, and no place else usually. It go so that I became self-conscious about it even though I was happy with my attire and my husband was pleased as well. Still, I tried to dress down a bit, find a more balanced way to look nice. That failed, too. Why it mattered to me whether I fit in with the sweats and flip flops brigade is a mystery.
Actually, it’s not a mystery. A few years ago, right around the time I started blogging in fact, it became clear to me that we (women, that is) are fairly well obsessed with performing for others. It feels uncomfortable to describe it that way and we may not want to acknowledge it, but that’s what it is. Forget the bravado you hear from those women who claim they could care less what anyone thinks of them. It is simply not true. We can learn to rise above the tendency, but it requires conscious effort.
I don’t get out much to do things or go places that don’t involve my family. That’s not a complaint. It’s simply a reality of life as a wife and mother of 5 children. There isn’t a lot of time for socializing and lunch dates with friends. As a result I’ve been pretty good at shaking off that innate feminine tendency to want to fit in with other women, but I’m not immune to the whispers of inadequacy that can come as a result of being the only one who (insert anomaly here). When I was a young bride I was dogged by the whispers, but now they don’t last long when they get through at all. I’ve learned to silence them quickly, by narrowing my focus.
The adult I spend the most time with is my husband, so it’s natural that I turn my energies toward what he likes and needs. Paul admonished those wanting to be married that it would be so, and there’s nothing wrong with that. He also admonished women to encourage one another in our home endeavors. Full time wives and mothers are a minority, so it’s hard to find others to build camaraderie with. It’s challenging being a relic in a world where value and productivity are measured chiefly in dollars and cents. Finding like-minded ladies can create a sense of belonging, but can also open the door to dangerous comparisons.
When you combine this with the innate feminine tendency to compare and measure ourselves against anything and everything, it can make for a disquieting existence. I realize that men can be competitive and experience stress, and all of those things, but it’s different for us. The fact that there networks of blogs, websites, magazines, talk shows, and books with the express intent of advising and encouraging women makes it obvious that women are more prone to this tendency than men are. Men have their own sets of challenges, but this is about us.
It’s taken me a while, but I’ve learned a valuable lesson from watching my husband over the past 2 decades. That lesson is that it’s better to set your goals, set your sights, and stay focused without allowing the opinions of others to toss you this way and that. I’ve found that men tend to be better in general at doing this.
I would usually go out of my way to tell women not to try to be like men, but this is one area where I’ll make an exception. Thankfully as it turns out, this ability to keep one’s eye on the prize isn’t one that only men should cultivate. The idea of singleness of heart is found throughout Scripture, and as long as our hearts are turned toward the thing that God has called us to, we have the ability to tune out the voices that call to us to ignore those things that are most important in an attempt to fit in.
For the Christian wife, the opinions of the ladies at the PTA or mid-week Bible study are irrelevant when there are no clear issues of sin and righteousness up for discussion. We are to submit to God and our own husbands. Have you ever noticed that men tend to respect another man’s right to run his home as he sees fit? Women on the other hand, hold one another up to impossible standards. Impossible because we’re daughters of Eve, chronically discontent without a lot of prayer and internal work.
We go from being at ease in our own skin to being convinced that the sister with the floor-length dresses and head coverings is more holy, and emulate that. Suddenly the husband we respected and looked up to is flawed because he plays XBox on Saturday mornings while Sis. Smith’s husband leads the Saturday morning men’s prayer gathering. We get out of our place and start using our “godly influence” to nudge him in the right direction: away from his video game and toward the path to church ministry. We hate our house, our bodies, our jobs, and on and on it goes.
Life becomes one big performance depending on who is watching. There’s no peace in our hearts, no joy in our walk, no intimacy in our marriages, but we look good to those on the outside looking in. My life forever changed when I recognized the fruitlessness of religious theater. Experts say that women are unhappy, and they have myriad questions and theories about why. There’s no mystery here, really. It’s round the clock performance anxiety. It’s enough to make anyone stressed, irritable, and crazy. Even professional actors get days off.
Once you cease to care about owing anyone anything but the debt of love, the pressure to perform goes away. The drive to measure up to whichever arbitrary standard you’re face with today dissipates.
Hang up the mask, and put on the sundress if it’s what your husband prefer no matter what Sis. Smith has to say about it. You’ll eventually learn to rise above the subtle criticisms and judgmental looks.
Simply refuse to play the game. It’s the cure for feminine performance anxiety.
So true in so many ways.
Thanks Sis. I was worried that the first comment to come through would be one focused on fashion and immodesty, LOL, when that wasn’t at all my point.
It’s been quite a few years since I was in the PTA or gripped with many of the issues I described in this post, but I remember it all so clearly. I remember the feelings even more clearly. And even now, I sometimes have to remind myself not to be influenced by those who primary motivation is to validate their own choices by getting someone else to go along with them.
Thank you, Elspeth. Even though I feel I have narrowed my focus to only my husband and children in order to keep mindful of what’s most important and to keep out the “noise”, I can get back into the comparing game pretty quickly if I am not careful. Good reminders here.
And, I loved this: Once you cease to care about owing anyone anything but the debt of love, the pressure to perform goes away. So true.
I love this line: “My life forever changed when I recognized the fruitlessness of religious theater.” This is definitely something I am in the process of purging from my thought patterns, with Jesus’ help.
Excellent post, Elspeth.
There is much here that hits at something I’ve been working out.
Anyway, although there are several great points, this:
We go from being at ease in our own skin to being convinced that the sister with the floor-length dresses and head coverings is more holy, and emulate that.
particularly caught my eye as I live in an area with an extremely high concentration of a very conservative Christian sect (3 different variations, no less). And, I have to say that the pressure to simply conform to an external standard of “holiness” in spite of my husband’s direction is huge.
Oddly, I’m far more likely to veer into the weird world of hyper-fundamental legalism than into trying to look like “the world”. In the end, the result is the same as you already illuminated the fact that ignoring one’s husband’s preferences is simply rebellion to God’s instruction to wives. And honestly, I don’t think Satan much cares which lie we choose to swallow so long as we are NOT doing what we’ve been told.
More to the point, I’d been feeling growing uneasiness for several years about being so “liberal” with my own wardrobe.
But recently, some things were brought to my attention that highlighted the reality that we can visually separate ourselves from the world in innumerable ways, but it can never fully cover the ugliness of disrespect for others or the self-absorbed pride that can fester beneath the whitewashed exterior.
Last Sunday, I had to sit down w/ hubby before we went to church and ask his forgiveness for being so stubborn about asking for his input with one hand open and then with the other hand, measuring his words against every other opinion I came across.
He was gracious…he always is
I love this post! I don’t generally feel too anxious about my style of dress…for me it’s about my children’s “performance”. If their behavior is off, I feel really anxious about being judged, especially in front of people at church. Also, we’ve decided not to push our kids so much with lessons anymore; for awhile they were in too many activities and it was so stressful. Now it’s more relaxed, but I do tense up a little whenever someone asks what they are involved in – I feel like I need a long list, and if I don’t have it, I need to justify why not.
-loud clapping-
This post hits the nail right on the head and is very much addressing much of what I’ve been working through in my own thought life.
Brava, m’lady. Brava.
All I have to say is…don’t bash the flip-flops.
All I have to say is…don’t bash the flip-flops.
Oh, I wear my share of flip flops Joanna. It’s the Florida way you know. I try to make sure they’re attractive flip flops, not your standard rubber flat one fit for nothing more than the beach or the shower of a public gym, LOL.
Thanks, Hearthie,
.
@Sunshine Mary:
I am beginning to deal with the issue as it relates to our younger children whom we’re starting to homeschool, and I’m having to learn not to be swayed from confidence in what we have decided is best for our kids. I’m getting a little bit of practice since we’ve been questioned a bit about the fact that our three older girls will all be living at home while they attend college.
@ Heather:
The only times I’ve really struggled with this were when I wanted to embrace a more legalistic way of presenting myself as well. It seemed to me that long dresses, high neck lines and head coverings were synonymous with a woman who is supremely spiritual, disconnected from the culture and it’s trappings. That may be true for many women, but I know for a fact that it isn’t necessarily true.
Additionally and more importantly, my husband isn’t interested in having his wife dressed that way. So it was a sign of rebellion if I rejected what he wanted in favor of what looked holy to others.
We don’t live in an area with many religious sects. I was motivated by a desire to be different. I have happily settled into a peaceful place but I know many women still struggle with these issues as Christian husbands (or at least mine) is more concerned with being righteous than looking righteous. And he wants to enjoy looking at his wife.
Excellent post!
Mary Ellen
The Working Home Keeper
It seemed to me that long dresses, high neck lines and head coverings were synonymous with a woman who is supremely spiritual, disconnected from the culture and it’s trappings.
(Wryly chuckles to self),
If we were only visiting this area, had never visited a “dresses only” teaching site, and such trappings were an occasional oddity, I’d probably never even think about it.
Additionally and more importantly, my husband isn’t interested in having his wife dressed that way. So it was a sign of rebellion if I rejected what he wanted in favor of what looked holy to others.
When my husband was a kid, he remembers attending a church which dictated the rules for all sorts of stuff. He recalls that there were some genuinely loving people and some not so (true for most church groups). But, he especially recalls the effect it had on him. The resulting “good little Pharisee” was great about being a stickler for enforcing the official behavioral statements while ignoring the heart issues of pride (over being more “righteous” than others) and a contentious spirit.
When I started making noise about how much more holy the women in the local groups appear, he said “I know what legalism does. We are NOT going to become XYZ’s”. Thankfully, the Lord’s opened my eyes to be able to see some of what he’s been saying.
I really, REALLY appreciate your point about ignoring your husband’s thoughts in favor of what others say a proper Christian woman ought to look like. Obviously, if he had decided to submit to a local group which insisted on a certain uniform look, you’d be obligated to obey. But that is not your situation. Nor is it mine.
The Apostle was not speaking from ignorance when he wrote that wives are to submit to our own husbands. There are literally thousands of contradictory opinions about how to apply biblical principles when living in “modern” society. Even those who agree on greater issues (ie women must have long hair and only wear dresses) differ in the details regarding length, color, style–even whether it’s okay to wear pantyhose!)
.
Women seem to be especially disposed to break ranks and follow whatever convincing argument happens to poke our emotions at the moment. The divided loyalties that come from listening to everyone BUT the husband are highly destructive.
As my previous comments look a bit as though I’m suggesting that Christians who hold to a particular style of dress are hypocrites; I wanted to add that I take no issue with the fact that some are convicted on a heart level to wear certain clothing or associate with a particular group. That is between them and the Lord.
It was just such a relief to finally be able to see how it is “easy” to focus mainly on one’s outward appearance while ignoring the need to develop such character qualities as humility and compassion. The problem is not so much with “them” as it is in recognizing the emphasis *I* was placing on appearances.
Great ideas! I have made this switch in my thinking recently and it has been liberating. I don’t always dress the way my peers do, but who cares! My husband is usually happy with what I am wearing, and that is far more important to me than what others are thinking.
Glad you said this, Elspeth.
The other thing, of course, about the religous theatre is that everyone is acting. Super holy. You must be prayerful, holy, with perrrfect kids and a husband who is just so gosh-darn Godly.
Many of the women who act that way are simply lying. They often are ignoring their husband (if they have not kicked him out for playing Xbox because that leads to dancing) and they are inoculating their kids against the church. Or they are micromanaging their husband — which never works.
As a man, the opinion about dress I should listen to is that of my wife (and my boss: dress codes etc.). Not anyone else. The converse applies.